I first found out about the Disney Mystery VHS Keychains in an email my family received from the shopdisney.com website, advertising new products. The keychains were part of a '90s Flashback Collection that Disney had launched, and some of the other items in the collection (like journals and clutch bags) also used the VHS case motif. However, the keychains are what really got my attention, partially because I collect keychains, but also because I have a thing for miniatures. This might trace back to my days collecting Basic Fun's mini board game keychains. Or it might be because I'm also a doll collector who knows the value of nice, doll-sized props. Whatever the case, when pictures of those Disney VHS Keychains appeared in my family's inbox it was love at first sight. So I clicked the link to the website for more information.
I'll admit, I was a little disappointed when I found out the keychains were a blind box item. I don't usually have very good luck with blind boxes. However, of the six different keychains that were available in the assortment, all four of the ones pictured on the website would've been welcome in my collection. The other two keychains were 'mystery chasers', and were supposed to be a surprise. However, by comparing the four known keychains to the full list of merchandise that was available in the collection, and by using process of elimination, I was able to make an educated guess what those 'mystery chasers' were. With the odds of getting something I liked in my favor, I decided that it would be worth taking a chance. The $5.00 retail price also seemed very reasonable for an official Disney product. So at the next available opportunity, I took a trip to the nearest Disney Store.
The store had stocked a nice assortment of merchandise from the '90s Flashback Collection. However, I didn't see any sign of the keychains. I wondered if the store had already sold out, so I asked an employee for help. It turned out the store hadn't even gotten in any of the Mystery VHS Keychains. I was annoyed when I realized that the only way I was going to get my hands on one was if I ordered it online, because that meant there would be shipping and handling charges. In my opinion, online shipping often seems unnecessarily high. There are times when it costs more to ship an item than you paid for the item in the first place. But lucky for me, the shopdisney.com website held one of their holiday free shipping promotions, so I was able to place an order for one keychain. The website's review section was already packed with complaints from people who'd ordered multiple keychains at once and had received all duplicates.
When my package arrived, the brown cardboard shipping box was much bigger than it needed to be for a single keychain. I understand that there should be some extra room in a shipping box for packing materials, but this box could have easily fit the full assortment of keychains and then some. The blind box itself is pictured below.
And here's a picture of the keychain I received.
As you can see, I ended up with The Hunchback Of Notre Dame, which was one of the 'mystery chasers'. I'm not sure if this means it's rarer than the other keychains. There seem to be a large number of The Hunchback Of Notre Dame VHS keychains on Ebay. But I'm unclear if this means it's not rare, or if it's just not as desirable, or both. Even though The Hunchback Of Notre Dame isn't one of my favorite Disney films, I don't mind having it in keychain form.
In my opinion, the coolest thing about these keychains is that they really open, and each one has a pretend VHS tape inside.
However, the first time I tried to open mine I needed to use more force than I was comfortable with. I was actually worried that I was going to break the keychain. Also, the plastic seems a bit thin, especially in the hinge area. I can't help worrying that repeatedly opening and closing the case will put stress on the area, and that over time the plastic might crack. Not to mention, the sticker labels on the outside of the case seem like they would be very vulnerable to scratches and other wear and tear. For these reasons, I don't think I'll be handling this keychain a lot.
I'll wrap this review up with a summary of what I feel are the good points and the bad points about this product.
Good Points:
In my opinion, the Oh My Disney Mystery VHS Keychains are a fun idea. I love the '90s nostalgia factor, and the fact that the keychains are miniature replicas of full-size items. The retail price was also reasonable, especially considering how much Disney often charges for authorized merchandise.
Bad Points:
The Disney company loses some points with me for making these keychains a blind box item. I never fully embraced the blind box craze. While I appreciate that blind boxes are small and usually reasonably priced, the mystery factor drives me crazy. I like to know what I'm buying, and several times that I've caved and bought a blind box on clearance I ended up with something I didn't really want. I feel sorry for all those customers who posted reviews online after placing an order for more than one keychain and receiving all duplicates. I'm also annoyed that the Mystery VHS Keychains weren't available in store. Not to mention I have some concerns about the long-term durability of these items.
Final Verdict:
While I don't regret buying a Disney Mystery VHS Keychain at retail price, I also don't think it would be worthwhile to go scouring the secondary market for the rest of the assortment, at least, not at the current market prices.
I hope you enjoyed this review, even if it is late.
Signed, Treesa
